Miley wrote ''Giving You Up'', not Amy.

''No it isn't by Amy Belle. It was suppossed to be on her Breakout Album but no one knows why they didn't took it. One year later Amy Belle took it.''

''Btw, I just wanted you know that Miley did write this. But then she decided not to use it for her records and so her staff sold it to that woman who released it and also made a video about it. So in a certain way THIS is the original, but it will always stay like UNRELEASED.''